💸 How We Handle Non-Paying Tenants — Like Professionals
If you’re in real estate long enough, you’ll face it: a tenant who stops paying rent. It’s frustrating, but you can’t let emotions take over. You have to handle it like a business. Over the years, I’ve tested a lot of approaches. Some were smart. Some… not so much. Here are the top strategies that actually work and the mistakes you should never make. ✅ 1. Offer Cash for Keys Yes, you read that right. I’ll walk up to the tenant and say, “I’ll pay you to leave.” Why? Because it’s faster and cheaper than months of lost rent and legal fees. We’ve paid anywhere from $2,000 to $4,000 to have someone hand over the keys and walk away. Time is money. The faster I can renovate, place a paying tenant, and refinance, the better. ✅ 2. Go Legal if You Have To If they refuse the offer? Fine. We bring in the attorney and start the formal eviction. It takes longer, but it’s clean, it’s legal, and it keeps your reputation intact. Sometimes you can’t avoid this step but don’t skip straight to it without trying negotiation first. 🚫 3. What NOT to Do: Never Cut Utilities I learned this one the hard way. Early on, I thought turning off water or power would force them out faster. Big mistake. It’s illegal, and it almost got me sued. We got lucky. You might not. So don’t even think about it no matter how tempting it feels in the moment. Key Takeaways: 🔹 Stay professional. This is business, not personal. 🔹 Always weigh the cost of time vs. pride. 🔹 Avoid illegal shortcuts that can destroy your reputation. 🔹 Protect your cash flow and keep your operation moving. At the end of the day, real estate isn’t about proving a point. It’s about keeping your income steady and your name clean. Play it smart. Every time.